Hey there, running enthusiasts! Ever found yourself staring at two pairs of New Balance shoes, the More v4 and v5, wondering which one deserves a spot in your shoe rack? You're not alone! The New Balance More series has gained a loyal following, and the jump from v4 to v5 has sparked plenty of debate. So, grab your favorite pre-run snack, and let's dive into this comparison, fueled by the wisdom of Reddit and my own personal insights. We'll explore the key differences, the pros and cons, and ultimately, help you decide which shoe might be the perfect fit for your feet. This isn't just about specs; it's about the feel, the ride, and how these shoes translate to your individual running experience. Get ready to have your questions answered, and maybe even discover your new favorite running companion.

The Core Differences: What Sets Them Apart?

Alright, let's get down to the nitty-gritty. The New Balance More v4 and v5 share a common ancestor, but they've evolved in distinct ways. The most significant change between the two versions lies in the midsole. The v4 utilizes Fresh Foam X, known for its plush cushioning and responsiveness. Many runners praise the v4 for its comfort on long runs and recovery days. It's like running on a cloud! The v5, on the other hand, also boasts Fresh Foam X, but the formulation and design have been tweaked. New Balance aimed to enhance stability and energy return. This often translates to a slightly firmer feel compared to the v4, but with improved responsiveness, which might appeal to runners who enjoy a more energetic ride. The upper construction also sees some changes. The v4 often features a more traditional, breathable mesh, while the v5 might introduce a redesigned upper that focuses on better lockdown and a more secure fit. Think of it like a hug for your foot, keeping you snug and secure throughout your run. The outsole, the part of the shoe that meets the road, might also undergo some updates. These could involve changes to the rubber compound or the tread pattern, designed to improve durability and grip. While the core philosophy of the More series—maximum cushioning—remains, these subtle shifts can significantly alter the overall feel and performance of each shoe. It is important to remember that these are general observations. Individual experiences can vary depending on foot strike, running style, and personal preferences.

Furthermore, the v5 often incorporates design elements focused on improved breathability and a more streamlined aesthetic. Some Redditors have noted that the v5 feels slightly lighter than the v4, contributing to a more agile feel. This doesn't mean the v4 is clunky, but rather, the v5 aims to deliver the same level of comfort with a touch of enhanced performance. Consider the v4 as your classic, reliable friend, always there for you with unwavering support, and the v5 as the more athletic, energetic version ready to push your limits. Ultimately, understanding these core differences is essential in determining which shoe better aligns with your running needs and preferences. So, let’s dig deeper into the specifics, comparing the features and user experiences to get a comprehensive understanding of these running shoes. Understanding the core changes is really the key to figuring out which one is the right choice for you.

Comfort and Cushioning: A Battle of Softness

When it comes to the New Balance More v4 vs v5, comfort and cushioning are paramount. The More series is renowned for its generous stack height and plush ride, and both versions aim to deliver an exceptional experience. The v4, as mentioned before, often receives accolades for its incredibly soft feel. The Fresh Foam X midsole is engineered to absorb impact, making it ideal for those long runs and recovery days when your legs need a break. Reddit users frequently describe the v4 as feeling like running on a cloud, a sensation that promotes comfort and reduces fatigue. The cushioning is designed to cradle your feet, providing a luxurious experience that minimizes the stress on your joints. This makes the v4 an excellent choice for runners prone to injuries or those who prefer a more relaxed running style. The v5, while still prioritizing comfort, might present a slightly firmer experience. This doesn't mean it's less comfortable; it's more about a different kind of feel. The tweaked Fresh Foam X formulation aims to balance cushioning with responsiveness. This means you still get plenty of impact absorption, but you might also feel a bit more energy return with each stride. This can be beneficial for runners who like to pick up the pace or incorporate speed work into their routine.

The upper construction also plays a role in the overall comfort. The v4's traditional mesh often allows for excellent breathability, keeping your feet cool and comfortable even during warmer runs. The v5 may introduce a redesigned upper that focuses on a more secure fit, which can enhance the feeling of support and stability. Some Redditors have noted that the v5's upper provides a more snug feel, which can improve the overall running experience. The key takeaway here is that both shoes deliver impressive comfort, but in slightly different ways. If you prioritize maximum softness and a cloud-like feel, the v4 might be your best bet. If you want a balance of cushioning and responsiveness, the v5 could be a better choice. The best way to determine which shoe wins in the comfort battle is to try them both on and feel the difference for yourself. Head to your local running store and take a few steps in each pair. This firsthand experience will tell you which one better suits your feet and running style.

Performance and Responsiveness: Picking Up the Pace

While the New Balance More v4 and v5 are known for their comfort, they also strive to provide a good level of performance. This is where the subtle differences in the midsole and design come into play. The v4, with its focus on plush cushioning, can be a great option for easy runs and recovery days. Its soft ride absorbs impact efficiently, helping to reduce fatigue and protect your joints. However, some runners might find it less responsive compared to the v5, especially when trying to pick up the pace. The v5, designed with improved responsiveness, can offer a more energetic feel underfoot. The tweaked Fresh Foam X formulation and potentially a slightly firmer midsole can translate to a snappier ride. This means you might feel more propulsive energy return with each stride, which can be beneficial during tempo runs, interval training, or even faster-paced long runs. The updated upper design in the v5, with its focus on a more secure fit, can also contribute to improved performance. A snug-fitting upper can enhance the feeling of control and stability, allowing you to run with greater confidence.

Another factor to consider is the weight. While the More series isn't designed to be a lightweight racing shoe, the v5 might feel slightly lighter than the v4 due to refinements in the materials and design. This can enhance your running experience if you are looking for a more agile feel. However, it's important to remember that the More series prioritizes cushioning over weight savings. The outsole also plays a role in performance. While the v4’s outsole offers reliable grip, the v5 might include some adjustments to the rubber compound or tread pattern for better traction and durability. This can improve your confidence when running on various surfaces and in different weather conditions. Ultimately, the performance aspect depends on your individual running style and goals. If you are looking for a shoe primarily for easy runs and maximum comfort, the v4 could be a great choice. If you want a more responsive ride that can handle faster paces, the v5 might be the better option. Consider the type of runs you usually do and what you value most in a running shoe. Do you need maximum cushioning or a bit of extra pep? Trying both shoes and comparing how they feel during different types of runs is the best way to determine which one aligns with your performance needs.

Fit and Feel: Getting the Right Fit

Getting the right fit is crucial for any running shoe, and the New Balance More v4 and v5 are no exception. Both shoes aim to offer a comfortable and secure fit, but there might be some subtle differences to consider. The v4 often features a more traditional fit, with a breathable mesh upper that provides ample room for your toes to splay. Many runners find the v4 to be true to size, but it's always recommended to try them on before purchasing. Some Redditors have noted that the v4 might feel slightly wider in the toe box, which can be a benefit for runners with wider feet or those who prefer more space. The v5, on the other hand, might feature a redesigned upper that focuses on a more secure and snug fit. This could mean a slightly more streamlined design, which could appeal to runners who prefer a closer feel. However, this could also mean that the v5 might fit a bit narrower, so it is essential to try them on to ensure a comfortable fit.

The upper materials also play a role in the overall feel. The v4's traditional mesh usually allows for excellent breathability, keeping your feet cool and comfortable. The v5 might introduce some changes to the upper materials, potentially incorporating more supportive elements or a more streamlined design. It is also important to consider the overall shape of the shoe. Both the v4 and v5 have a high stack height, which can affect the feel underfoot. Some runners might feel like they are sitting a bit higher in the v5, thanks to potential adjustments to the midsole and outsole design. Pay close attention to how the shoe feels in the heel and midfoot. A secure fit in these areas is crucial for stability and preventing slippage. Another thing to think about is the lacing system. Ensure the laces provide a secure and adjustable fit without creating pressure points. The best way to determine the right fit is to try both shoes on in person. Go to your local running store and take your time walking and running in each pair. Pay attention to how your feet feel in the toe box, midfoot, and heel. Make sure you have enough room for your toes to move comfortably and that the shoe provides adequate support. If possible, bring your running socks to ensure an accurate fit. Consider any specific needs or preferences you have, such as a preference for a wider toe box or a more secure heel fit. Finding the right fit is about finding a shoe that feels comfortable and supportive for your feet.

Reddit Reviews and User Experiences: What the Community Says

Alright, let's tap into the collective wisdom of Reddit. When discussing the New Balance More v4 and v5, the community offers a treasure trove of insights. Generally, the v4 receives high praise for its exceptional comfort. Users frequently highlight its plush cushioning, making it a favorite for long runs and recovery days. Many Redditors describe it as a truly enjoyable running experience, perfect for those seeking maximum impact protection. Some users, however, find the v4 to be less responsive than other options, which is not necessarily a bad thing, depending on their running goals. The lack of responsiveness may not be ideal for speed work or tempo runs. The v5, on the other hand, seems to be gaining popularity for its balanced approach. Users appreciate the enhanced responsiveness, which adds a bit more pep to the ride. Many reviewers indicate that the v5 is slightly firmer than the v4. Although, it still provides plenty of cushioning. This makes it a great choice for a wider range of activities. Some have noted that the v5 feels a bit more stable, thanks to the redesigned upper and midsole.

Redditors also discuss fit and sizing. Some suggest that the v4 runs true to size, while others recommend going up half a size, especially if you have wider feet. It is always a good idea to try both shoes on to ensure the perfect fit. The discussions on Reddit often delve into the specific running styles and preferences of each user. Some users find that the v4 is ideal for easy runs and everyday training, while others prefer the v5 for more varied workouts. It is not uncommon to see discussions about how the shoe performs on different surfaces and in different weather conditions. Some reviewers are also keen to share their experiences with the durability of each shoe, discussing how the outsole and midsole hold up over time. Some users also offer valuable insights into the shoe’s pros and cons. They are frequently used to express positive comments such as comfort and cushioning. Other common reviews address the breathability of the upper. Other users' comments focus on areas like the midsole and overall design. When considering Reddit reviews, it's essential to remember that experiences vary. Read several reviews and consider the feedback from runners with similar needs and preferences. Also, it is always a good idea to visit a local running store to try on both shoes.

Which Shoe Should You Choose?

So, after all this, which shoe comes out on top? The answer, as it often does, is: it depends! Both the New Balance More v4 and v5 are excellent running shoes, but they cater to slightly different needs. If you prioritize maximum comfort, the cloud-like feel, and a more relaxed ride, the v4 is an excellent choice. It's perfect for long runs, recovery days, and those who want a shoe that prioritizes cushioning. If you want a balance of cushioning, responsiveness, and a more energetic ride, the v5 might be a better fit. Its improved responsiveness makes it suitable for a wider range of activities, including tempo runs and faster-paced workouts. If you have run in the New Balance More series before, it will likely be easier to make a decision. If you have wide feet, consider the v4 for its potentially roomier toe box. If you prefer a more secure, snug fit, the v5 might be a better option. Consider the type of runs you usually do and what you value most in a running shoe. Do you need maximum cushioning or a bit of extra pep? The best way to decide is to try both shoes on and compare how they feel. Ultimately, the best shoe is the one that feels the most comfortable and supportive for your feet. Consider your running style, any specific needs or preferences you have, and your budget. Remember to read reviews, talk to other runners, and consult with a running shoe specialist to ensure you make the right choice. Running should be a joy, so select the shoe that maximizes your experience and helps you achieve your goals. Happy running!